Page 81 - 2015_WhitePaper_web
P. 81
e American Chamber of Commerce in South China
????³é©³???æ³¢ç????????????讼è?æ±????æ³¢ç?ä¸?? å®???¶æ????è¦???©ç?ä¹?????äº?½¿?¨è´¹????½¿?¨è´¹
?????ä¸??ï¼??广ä????级人æ°???¢æ?èµ·ä?è¯?????¢æ? ??????ï¼???¹å?å½???§å?å¹³ã?????????è§??款ï?
??äº??????¢å?æ³°å????èµ·ç?æ¡?»¶ä¸???³ç?æ³?????ï¼? ?³â??RAND???款è?è¡????????ä¸???¶ï???»¥è¯·æ?äº?
é«?º§äººæ?æ³??????????????§å¹¶?¨å????äº??æ³¢ç?ä¸? æ°???¢è??³ã??ººæ°???¢æ???????è¦???©ç??¹ç?ï¼????
??????????讼è?æ±????é«?ººæ°???¢é©³???????³è??? å®??该ä??©æ?类似ä¸?????·å?æ¶???¶å?è¢????ºº?¸å?äº?
??????æ¶????????¥ä¸?????ä¾?????©è???½¿?¨è´¹ä¸?
???ä¸???¸å?ä¿¡æ?ä¾µå????ç§??çº?º·æ¡? åº??è¿?º§???æ¶??å®??ä¾???´ç??¥å¹²???ï¼?»¼???????
ä¸???¸ä??´ä??©è????????µç?å·??ï¼?»¥???为å??¸å?
?£è?ç§???½é????????±ç??¹å?å·¥ï?ä¸?µ·ï¼????? ??½¿??DC????¨ä¸?½ä?å¤?????å¿??ä¸??è¿???????
?¸ï?ç®?称å??±ç??¹ä?æµ·å??¸ï????æµ·å?ç¬??ä¸?º§äººæ?æ³? ä»?½¿?¨è´¹?????,???ç¡?????????©è???½¿?¨è´¹??
?¢è?ç§?P-1068产å????产æ?ç¨???·¥?ºã????¹ç?????¿¡
???äº???±ç??¹å?????¢ç????ç§?????????·å?ç³»å? ??¸º?????????¸ï?ç®?称å?为å??¸ï?ä¸?DC???å°?
?±ç??¹ä?æµ·å??¸å?å·¥ï?离è????ä¸?¿°???ç§?????ç»?? IDC????¥æ????äº???©è???´¹???è¿??äº??次è??¤ã??
?°é?主å?å¥??å¼??æ¸????·¥??????ï¼??称å?å¥???¸ï? è°?????ï¼?DC???请æ?ç¾???½é?è´¸æ?å§??ä¼????¸º??
???å¥???¸ä½¿?¨ä?两å????æ¶?????ç§???³è?äº??ç§? ?¸ç??¸å?产å????337è°?????为å??¸é???¹¿ä¸??æ·±å?
为â????ºé?????????º§???è¿?·¥?ºâ??????ä¸????¸¤ å¸?¸çº§äººæ°???¢æ?èµ·è?讼ï?è¦??æ³???¤ä»¤IDC??????
???请æ?æ³???¤ä»¤ä¸¤è????æ?½¿?¨å????ç§??并è??¿ç? ??¹³????????æ§è?ï¼?RANDï¼?????ç¡?????ä¸??è®?
æµ??å¤?200ä¸?????æµ·å?ç¬??ä¸?º§äººæ?æ³??ç»?????è®? ??´¹????·±?³å?ä¸?º§äººæ?æ³??认为?¹æ????å¹³ã???????
为å??·ç???¸»????????º§SL-1801产å?使ç??????¿¡ ???è§??????????å¿??ä¸??许å?使ç?è´¹ç?åº?¡®å®?¸º
???两å????ä¸??å¯??????¿¡???è´¨ä????????³é©³?? 0.019%??DC?????¹¿ä¸??é«?º§äººæ?æ³????µ·ä¸????¹¿
两å????è¯??请æ???¸¤???ä¸??ï¼??èµ·ä?è¯??äº??æ³?? ä¸??é«?º§äººæ?æ³??认为ï¼????????æ´²ç?ä¿¡æ???????
ç»´æ??????¸çº§äººæ°???¢å?ä½???¤å??¶ä¸¥?¼è????å®?? ????½ç?ä¿¡å·¥ä¸??ä¼?¸???è¯?º§???ç??ä¸??æ³?????
并ç?ä¸??è¿??äº??ä¸??å®??? ?³è?å®????RAND???æ±???©æ?人æ????äº??????¡ã??
???ï¼??äº?????ä»????½¿?¨è´¹?????????使ç????
???å¿??ä¸??许å?使ç?è´¹æ?ä»? ???å¿??ä¸????ººä¸??å¾?????许å????为å??¸å?IDC
Standard Essential Patent Royalty Case ??????欧洲?µä¿¡??????ä¼?????ï¼??æ?DC???è´?
??????为å??¸å??½å?ä¸??????¡ï?许å?è´¹ç?åº??å½??
??¸º?????????¸ï?ç®?称å?为å??¸ï?ä¸?DC???å°? ?§å?å¹³ã?????????è§??款ï??³â??RAND???款确å®???
???å¿??ä¸??许å?è´¹æ???´¹???é¢??è¡??å¤??è°??ï¼? ???ä¸???¶ï??±æ??¢è??³ã???æ¡??ä¸??é¦?????å¿??ä¸?
è°?????ï¼?DC???????½æ??¢æ?èµ·è?讼ï????请æ?ç¾? ?©ä½¿?¨è´¹çº?º·ï¼??次é?????RAND?????????ä¸??è¦?
?½å???´¸??????对å?为å??¸ç??¸å?产å????337è°?? ???ä¾??件ã??
并å?å¸???¢ç?æ¢è??£ä»¤?????????????»¤???为å?
?¸é???¹¿ä¸??æ·±å?å¸?¸çº§äººæ°???¢æ?èµ·è?讼ï?è¦??æ³?? ???象â??©°???????¤æ?
?¤ä»¤IDC????????¹³????????æ§è?ï¼?RANDï¼?????
ç¡?????ä¸??许å?è´¹ç???¹¿ä¸??æ·±å?å¸?¸çº§äººæ°????? æ²³å?广太?³è??¿ä???????ï¼??称广å¤???¸ï???
审è?为ï??¹æ????å¹³ã????????æ§è??????????å¿?? ???ä¸??ä¸?????象â???ä¸?ä¸??ç«?¤§è±¡ç?????¾å½¢???
ä¸??许å?使ç?è´¹ç?åº?¡®å®?¸º0.019%??DC???ä¸??ä¸?å®? ??????该å????2003å¹?3??21?¥è?å¾?³¨????¸å?使ç?
?¤å?ï¼??广ä????级人æ°???¢æ?èµ·ä?è¯???¹¿ä¸??é«?º§äº? ?¨â?????????????°´æ³¥â??????ä¸????象é??¢æ????
æ°?????审è?为ï???????å??ä¸??解ï?è¿???¹æ?欧洲 ?¸ï?ç®?称å?象é????????????象å??¾â????????ººï¼?
?µä¿¡??????ä¼??ç¾???µä¿¡å·¥ä????ä¸???¥è?产æ??¿ç? 该å????1997å¹?5??14?¥è?å¾????³¨????¸å?使ç??¨â??
??¸?½æ?å¾???¸å?è§??ï¼???RAND????¡ç????????? ?°æ???????ä¸????象é??¢å????è¯??å§??ä¼???ºæ???
解为???å¹³ã????????æ§è????????¡ï?对ä??¿æ???? 广太?????????请ï??¶ç??±ä¸»è¦?¸ºå¹¿å¤ª????????³»
???使ç?è´¹ç?????????½¿?¨è??????å¿??ä¸????ººä¸? 对å?é©°å??????????仿ï?äº????????使ç???????
å¾???´æ?ç»??????¢è?ä¿??ä¸????ºº?½å?ä»??????°ä¸ ????¿â??????§å?强ã???象é??¢å??°æ?è¡?????é«????
?·å?足å?????¥ï????ä¹????????è¦???©æ??©äºº??? ??º¦??½±???ï¼??使ç?建ç???????ä¼?????ä¸?¿°ç±»ä¼¼
?????å½¢æ???¼º?¿å?ä½?´¢???é¢????´¹??????ä¸?? ???产ç?æ··æ???2009å¹?8??31?¥ï????è¯??å§??ä¼??ä¸?
???件ã????RAND????¡ç??¸å??¨ä???????æ§è???? ????¨æ?è¯??ä¸?¶³ä»¥è????è®?????注å?????£è±¡???
??´¹???????´¹???ç¡?????为å??¸å?IDC??????æ¬? ?????????注ã???象é???????è£??ï¼????º¬å¸??ä¸?
æ´²ç?ä¿¡æ?????????????IDC???è´??许å???¸º??? ä¸?º§äººæ?æ³????µ·è¯?????äº??ç¬??ä¸?º§äººæ?æ³???¤é?
äº?????审å????????³ï?认为???象å??¾â??????ä¸?
81
????³é©³???æ³¢ç????????????讼è?æ±????æ³¢ç?ä¸?? å®???¶æ????è¦???©ç?ä¹?????äº?½¿?¨è´¹????½¿?¨è´¹
?????ä¸??ï¼??广ä????级人æ°???¢æ?èµ·ä?è¯?????¢æ? ??????ï¼???¹å?å½???§å?å¹³ã?????????è§??款ï?
??äº??????¢å?æ³°å????èµ·ç?æ¡?»¶ä¸???³ç?æ³?????ï¼? ?³â??RAND???款è?è¡????????ä¸???¶ï???»¥è¯·æ?äº?
é«?º§äººæ?æ³??????????????§å¹¶?¨å????äº??æ³¢ç?ä¸? æ°???¢è??³ã??ººæ°???¢æ???????è¦???©ç??¹ç?ï¼????
??????????讼è?æ±????é«?ººæ°???¢é©³???????³è??? å®??该ä??©æ?类似ä¸?????·å?æ¶???¶å?è¢????ºº?¸å?äº?
??????æ¶????????¥ä¸?????ä¾?????©è???½¿?¨è´¹ä¸?
???ä¸???¸å?ä¿¡æ?ä¾µå????ç§??çº?º·æ¡? åº??è¿?º§???æ¶??å®??ä¾???´ç??¥å¹²???ï¼?»¼???????
ä¸???¸ä??´ä??©è????????µç?å·??ï¼?»¥???为å??¸å?
?£è?ç§???½é????????±ç??¹å?å·¥ï?ä¸?µ·ï¼????? ??½¿??DC????¨ä¸?½ä?å¤?????å¿??ä¸??è¿???????
?¸ï?ç®?称å??±ç??¹ä?æµ·å??¸ï????æµ·å?ç¬??ä¸?º§äººæ?æ³? ä»?½¿?¨è´¹?????,???ç¡?????????©è???½¿?¨è´¹??
?¢è?ç§?P-1068产å????产æ?ç¨???·¥?ºã????¹ç?????¿¡
???äº???±ç??¹å?????¢ç????ç§?????????·å?ç³»å? ??¸º?????????¸ï?ç®?称å?为å??¸ï?ä¸?DC???å°?
?±ç??¹ä?æµ·å??¸å?å·¥ï?离è????ä¸?¿°???ç§?????ç»?? IDC????¥æ????äº???©è???´¹???è¿??äº??次è??¤ã??
?°é?主å?å¥??å¼??æ¸????·¥??????ï¼??称å?å¥???¸ï? è°?????ï¼?DC???请æ?ç¾???½é?è´¸æ?å§??ä¼????¸º??
???å¥???¸ä½¿?¨ä?两å????æ¶?????ç§???³è?äº??ç§? ?¸ç??¸å?产å????337è°?????为å??¸é???¹¿ä¸??æ·±å?
为â????ºé?????????º§???è¿?·¥?ºâ??????ä¸????¸¤ å¸?¸çº§äººæ°???¢æ?èµ·è?讼ï?è¦??æ³???¤ä»¤IDC??????
???请æ?æ³???¤ä»¤ä¸¤è????æ?½¿?¨å????ç§??并è??¿ç? ??¹³????????æ§è?ï¼?RANDï¼?????ç¡?????ä¸??è®?
æµ??å¤?200ä¸?????æµ·å?ç¬??ä¸?º§äººæ?æ³??ç»?????è®? ??´¹????·±?³å?ä¸?º§äººæ?æ³??认为?¹æ????å¹³ã???????
为å??·ç???¸»????????º§SL-1801产å?使ç??????¿¡ ???è§??????????å¿??ä¸??许å?使ç?è´¹ç?åº?¡®å®?¸º
???两å????ä¸??å¯??????¿¡???è´¨ä????????³é©³?? 0.019%??DC?????¹¿ä¸??é«?º§äººæ?æ³????µ·ä¸????¹¿
两å????è¯??请æ???¸¤???ä¸??ï¼??èµ·ä?è¯??äº??æ³?? ä¸??é«?º§äººæ?æ³??认为ï¼????????æ´²ç?ä¿¡æ???????
ç»´æ??????¸çº§äººæ°???¢å?ä½???¤å??¶ä¸¥?¼è????å®?? ????½ç?ä¿¡å·¥ä¸??ä¼?¸???è¯?º§???ç??ä¸??æ³?????
并ç?ä¸??è¿??äº??ä¸??å®??? ?³è?å®????RAND???æ±???©æ?人æ????äº??????¡ã??
???ï¼??äº?????ä»????½¿?¨è´¹?????????使ç????
???å¿??ä¸??许å?使ç?è´¹æ?ä»? ???å¿??ä¸????ººä¸??å¾?????许å????为å??¸å?IDC
Standard Essential Patent Royalty Case ??????欧洲?µä¿¡??????ä¼?????ï¼??æ?DC???è´?
??????为å??¸å??½å?ä¸??????¡ï?许å?è´¹ç?åº??å½??
??¸º?????????¸ï?ç®?称å?为å??¸ï?ä¸?DC???å°? ?§å?å¹³ã?????????è§??款ï??³â??RAND???款确å®???
???å¿??ä¸??许å?è´¹æ???´¹???é¢??è¡??å¤??è°??ï¼? ???ä¸???¶ï??±æ??¢è??³ã???æ¡??ä¸??é¦?????å¿??ä¸?
è°?????ï¼?DC???????½æ??¢æ?èµ·è?讼ï????请æ?ç¾? ?©ä½¿?¨è´¹çº?º·ï¼??次é?????RAND?????????ä¸??è¦?
?½å???´¸??????对å?为å??¸ç??¸å?产å????337è°?? ???ä¾??件ã??
并å?å¸???¢ç?æ¢è??£ä»¤?????????????»¤???为å?
?¸é???¹¿ä¸??æ·±å?å¸?¸çº§äººæ°???¢æ?èµ·è?讼ï?è¦??æ³?? ???象â??©°???????¤æ?
?¤ä»¤IDC????????¹³????????æ§è?ï¼?RANDï¼?????
ç¡?????ä¸??许å?è´¹ç???¹¿ä¸??æ·±å?å¸?¸çº§äººæ°????? æ²³å?广太?³è??¿ä???????ï¼??称广å¤???¸ï???
审è?为ï??¹æ????å¹³ã????????æ§è??????????å¿?? ???ä¸??ä¸?????象â???ä¸?ä¸??ç«?¤§è±¡ç?????¾å½¢???
ä¸??许å?使ç?è´¹ç?åº?¡®å®?¸º0.019%??DC???ä¸??ä¸?å®? ??????该å????2003å¹?3??21?¥è?å¾?³¨????¸å?使ç?
?¤å?ï¼??广ä????级人æ°???¢æ?èµ·ä?è¯???¹¿ä¸??é«?º§äº? ?¨â?????????????°´æ³¥â??????ä¸????象é??¢æ????
æ°?????审è?为ï???????å??ä¸??解ï?è¿???¹æ?欧洲 ?¸ï?ç®?称å?象é????????????象å??¾â????????ººï¼?
?µä¿¡??????ä¼??ç¾???µä¿¡å·¥ä????ä¸???¥è?产æ??¿ç? 该å????1997å¹?5??14?¥è?å¾????³¨????¸å?使ç??¨â??
??¸?½æ?å¾???¸å?è§??ï¼???RAND????¡ç????????? ?°æ???????ä¸????象é??¢å????è¯??å§??ä¼???ºæ???
解为???å¹³ã????????æ§è????????¡ï?对ä??¿æ???? 广太?????????请ï??¶ç??±ä¸»è¦?¸ºå¹¿å¤ª????????³»
???使ç?è´¹ç?????????½¿?¨è??????å¿??ä¸????ººä¸? 对å?é©°å??????????仿ï?äº????????使ç???????
å¾???´æ?ç»??????¢è?ä¿??ä¸????ºº?½å?ä»??????°ä¸ ????¿â??????§å?强ã???象é??¢å??°æ?è¡?????é«????
?·å?足å?????¥ï????ä¹????????è¦???©æ??©äºº??? ??º¦??½±???ï¼??使ç?建ç???????ä¼?????ä¸?¿°ç±»ä¼¼
?????å½¢æ???¼º?¿å?ä½?´¢???é¢????´¹??????ä¸?? ???产ç?æ··æ???2009å¹?8??31?¥ï????è¯??å§??ä¼??ä¸?
???件ã????RAND????¡ç??¸å??¨ä???????æ§è???? ????¨æ?è¯??ä¸?¶³ä»¥è????è®?????注å?????£è±¡???
??´¹???????´¹???ç¡?????为å??¸å?IDC??????æ¬? ?????????注ã???象é???????è£??ï¼????º¬å¸??ä¸?
æ´²ç?ä¿¡æ?????????????IDC???è´??许å???¸º??? ä¸?º§äººæ?æ³????µ·è¯?????äº??ç¬??ä¸?º§äººæ?æ³???¤é?
äº?????审å????????³ï?认为???象å??¾â??????ä¸?
81
